HMW DNA extraction strategies for complex metagenomes

Florian Trigodet

Table of Contents


The purpose of this page is to provide access to reproducible data products that underlie our key findings in the study “High molecular weight DNA extraction strategies for long-read sequencing of complex metagenomes” by Trigodet & Lolans et al.

Find the lab protocols of this work here.

In addition to the following data items, on this page you will find command lines for important analyses, results of which are discussed in the paper:

If you have any questions and/or if you are unable to find an important piece of information here, please feel free to leave a comment down below, send an e-mail to us, or get in touch with us through Discord:

Questions? Concerns? Find us on
High molecular weight DNA extraction strategies for long-read sequencing of complex metagenomes Trigodet F, Lolans K, Fogarty E, Shaiber A, Morrison HG, Barreiro L, Jabri B, Eren AM
- A study that benchmarks six high molecular weight DNA extraction strategies (commercially available kits, phenol-chloroform extraction, and agarose encasement followed by agarase digestion) for long-read sequencing of metagenomes with MinION.
- It turns out the protocol that works best for sequencing DNA from microbial isolates may not be the most effetive method for long-read sequencing of metagenomes ¯\_(ツ)_/¯
📚 Molecular Ecology Resources, 22(5):1786-1802 | 🔍 Google Scholar | 🔗 doi:10.1111/1755-0998.13588

Study description

Long read sequencing offers new opportunities for metagenomics studies, especially the ability to generate reads overlapping conserved or complex genomic regions which often fragments metagenome-assembled genomes when using short-reads.

Oxford Nanopore Technology, with sequencer like the MinION, offers no theoretical limits on sequence length. The practical limits are actually the DNA fragments obtained from the DNA extraction itself, therefore creating a revival of attention on high molecular weight (HMW) DNA extraction methodologies in the past few years.

We chose to compare different HMW DNA extractions in the context of metagenomics analysis and using a low biomass and host contaminated type of sample: the human oral cavity.

HMW DNA extraction protocols

We tested six HMW DNA extractions, but only three were able to generate enough DNA yield and purity to match the requirements for MinION sequencing. For these extraction methods, we had an original nomenclature (M#_#), which is different from the protocol’s name in the manuscript. Here is a table to summarize the three HMW DNA extraction methods, their replicates, variants, and also the additional sample used for amplicon and short-read sequencing.

DNA extractions sequenced with MinION (long-read metagenomes):

Sample Method Manuscript name Old name
oral_HMW Qiagen Genomic Tip 20/G with enzymatic treatment GT_1 M4_1
oral_HMW Qiagen Genomic Tip 20/G with enzymatic treatment GT_2 M4_2
oral_HMW Phenol/Chloroform Extraction PC_1 M5_1
oral_HMW Phenol/Chloroform Extraction PC_2 M5_2
oral_HMW Agarose Plug Encasement & Extraction AE_1 M6_1
oral_HMW Agarose Plug Encasement & Extraction AE_2 M6_2
oral_HMW Qiagen Genomic Tip 20/G with enzymatic treatment and size-selection GT_1_SS M4_1_SS
oral_HMW Qiagen Genomic Tip 20/G with enzymatic treatment and size-selection GT_2_SS M4_2_SS

DNA extractions sequenced with Illumina (short-read metagenomes):

Sample Method Manuscript name Old name
oral_HMW DNeasy PowerSoil Isolation Kit with modified bead beating PB_2 M1_2
oral_TD DNeasy Powersoil Isolation Kit TD TD

DNA extractions sequenced with Illumina (short-read amplicon):

Sample Method Manuscript name Old name
oral_TD DNeasy Powersoil Isolation Kit TD TD

Setting up your environment

For a better reproducibility, anyone can download the raw data and intermediate anvi’o contigs databases and create a directory to reproduce the analysis.

Here is the list of software required:

Most section will require the reader to create a tab delimited files with the name of samples and path to the appropriate data (raw sequences, assemblies). But let’s start by creating a working directory variable:

export WD="/path/to/your/working/directory/Trigodet_Lolans_et_al_2021/"

Mapping and removing of the human reads

In this first step, we are filtering out the long-reads mapping to the human genome. This part of the workflow is not fully reproducible since we asked to remove human read during the SRA submission. Any read identified as a human read by the SRA pipeline are replaced by a read of the same length, with Ns.

But you may still be interested in the way we removed and assessed the amount of human read contamination. You can get the fastq without the reads with Ns and still performed the mapping to the human genome, in case there were some differences between how SRA identifies human reads compare to us. To do that, you can use fastq-dump to download the raw fastq file with the argument --read-filter pass.

We want to remove human reads from all the long-read sequencing sample: GT_1, GT_2, PC_1, PC_2, AE_1, AE_2, GT_1_SS and GT_2_SS (the size selection samples).

We need a tab delimited text file with the following samples and the path to the raw long-reads, hereafter referred as raw_reads.txt:

sample  path
GT_1  /path/to/GT_1.fastq
GT_2  /path/to/GT_2.fastq
PC_1  /path/to/PC_1.fastq
PC_2  /path/to/PC_2.fastq
AE_1  /path/to/AE_1.fastq
AE_2  /path/to/AE_2.fastq
GT_1_SS  /path/to/GT_1_SS.fastq
GT_2_SS  /path/to/GT_2_SS.fastq

We also need your favorite humane genome (GRCh38), and index it with minimap2:

cd $WD

# create a directory for you to download the
# human genome
mkdir -p 00_LOGS
mkdir -p 01_RESOURCES


# replace the human genome file name with the
# one you have downloaded
minimap2 -x map-ont \
         -d GRCh38_latest_genomic.mmi \

Map the long reads with minimap2:

cd $WD

mkdir -p 02_MAPPING

while read sample path; do
  if [ "$sample" == "sample" ]; then continue; fi
    minimap2 -a 01_RESOURCES/HUMAN_GENOME/GRCh38_latest_genomic.mmi \
             $path \
             -t 10 \
             > 02_MAPPING/HUMAN_GENOME/$sample.sam
done < raw_reads.txt

Now, let’s filter out the reads mapping to the human genome:

cd $WD

mkdir -p 03_FASTA

while read sample path; do
  if [ "$sample" == "sample" ]; then continue; fi
  samtools view -F 4 02_MAPPING/HUMAN_GENOME/$sample.sam | cut -f 1 | sort -u > 02_MAPPING/HUMAN_GENOME/$sample-ids-to-remove.txt

  iu-remove-ids-from-fastq -i $path \
                           -l 02_MAPPING/HUMAN_GENOME/$sample-ids-to-remove.txt \
                           -d " "

  seqkit fq2fa -w 0 $path.survived > 03_FASTA/$sample-bacterial-reads.fa
  seqkit fq2fa -w 0 $path.removed > 03_FASTA/$sample-human-reads.fa

done < raw_reads.txt

Now we can assess the amount of human and microbial reads. Keep in mind that if you have downloaded the SRA fastq with the --read-filter pass, a majority of human reads have already been removed.

# total number of reads
while read sample path; do
  if [ "$sample" == "sample" ]; then continue; fi
  num_seq=$((`wc -l < $path` / 4))
  echo -e "$sample\t$num_seq"
done < raw_reads.txt

# microbial reads
for sample in `ls 03_FASTA/*-bacterial-reads.fa`; do
  num_seq=$((`wc -l < $sample` / 2))
  echo -e "$sample\t$num_seq"

# human reads
for sample in `ls 03_FASTA/*-human-reads.fa`; do
  num_seq=$((`wc -l < $sample` / 2))
  echo -e "$sample\t$num_seq"

Size distribution table and figure

Let’s generate anvi’o contigs databases with the microbial reads. They will be useful to summarize some read metrics, but also later for the taxonomic composition analysis.

We used the anvi’o build in snakemake workflow for contigs. To do that, we need a fasta.txt file, which should look like this if you have followed the above directory structure:

sample  path
GT_1  $WD/03_FASTA/GT_1-bacterial-reads.fa
GT_2  $WD/03_FASTA/GT_2-bacterial-reads.fa
PC_1  $WD/03_FASTA/PC_1-bacterial-reads.fa
PC_2  $WD/03_FASTA/PC_2-bacterial-reads.fa
AE_1  $WD/03_FASTA/AE_1-bacterial-reads.fa
AE_2  $WD/03_FASTA/AE_2-bacterial-reads.fa
GT_1_SS  $WD/03_FASTA/GT_1_SS-bacterial-reads.fa
GT_2_SS  $WD/03_FASTA/GT_2_SS-bacterial-reads.fa

We also need a config.json file which is used to pass arguments to the workflow command. You can modify it to change/increase the number of threads, run (or not) some optional commands, and the output directory. Here, the new directory will be 04_CONTIGS for the contigs.db. You can get a default config file like this:

anvi-run-workflow -w contigs --get-default-config config.json

Here is the workflow graph:

anvi-run-workflow -w contigs -c config.json --save-workflow-graph

cd $WD
anvi-run-workflow -w contigs -c config.json

Get some basic information:

anvi-display-contigs-stats -o 04_CONTIGS/contig_stats.txt 04_CONTIGS/*contigs.db

For the reads length distribution, we focused on the non-treated sample (no size selection). We need a file microbial_human_reads.txt with the sample name, path to the microbial and human reads:

name  microbial  human
GT_1  $WD/03_FASTA/GT_1-bacterial-reads.fa  $WD/03_FASTA/GT_1-human-reads.fa
GT_2  $WD/03_FASTA/GT_2-bacterial-reads.fa  $WD/03_FASTA/GT_2-human-reads.fa
PC_1  $WD/03_FASTA/PC_1-bacterial-reads.fa  $WD/03_FASTA/PC_1-human-reads.fa
PC_2  $WD/03_FASTA/PC_2-bacterial-reads.fa  $WD/03_FASTA/PC_2-human-reads.fa
AE_1  $WD/03_FASTA/AE_1-bacterial-reads.fa  $WD/03_FASTA/AE_1-human-reads.fa
AE_2  $WD/03_FASTA/AE_1-bacterial-reads.fa  $WD/03_FASTA/AE_1-human-reads.fa

Get the size distribution:

echo -e "sample\ttype\tlength" > size_distribution.txt
while read name microbial human; do
  if [ "$name" == "name" ]; then continue; fi
  awk -v name="$name" '/^>/{next}{print name "\tmicrobial\t"  length}' $microbial >> size_distribution.txt
  awk -v name="$name" '/^>/{next}{print name "\thuman\t"  length}' $human >> size_distribution.txt
done < microbial_human_reads.txt

Using R, we can plot the size distribution:



# import the data
size_distribution <- read.table("size_distribution.txt", header = T)

# create a group column for the three protocols
size_distribution$group <- ifelse(grepl("oral_HMW_4", size_distribution$sample), "M4",
                                  ifelse(grepl("oral_HMW_5", size_distribution$sample), "M5", "M6"))

# re-organize the samples
size_distribution$sample <- factor(size_distribution$sample, levels = c("oral_HMW_4_1", "oral_HMW_5_1", "oral_HMW_6_1", "oral_HMW_4_2", "oral_HMW_5_2", "oral_HMW_6_2"))

# create
breaks <- 10^(-10:10)
minor_breaks <- rep(1:9, 21)*(10^rep(-10:10, each=9))

# the ggplot function
P <- function(df){
  p <- ggplot(df, aes(length, fill = group, weight = length, alpha = type))
  p <- p + geom_histogram(bins = 40)
  p <- p + facet_wrap(. ~ sample, nrow = 2)
  p <- p + scale_alpha_discrete(range = c (0.6, 1))
  p <- p + scale_fill_manual(values = c("#007543", "#fa9f2e", "#0065a3"))
  p <- p + ylab("Sequencing yield (bp)")
  p <- p + xlab("Read length (bp)")
  p <- p + scale_x_log10(breaks = 10^(-10:10),
                         minor_breaks = rep(1:9, 21)*(10^rep(-10:10, each=9)))

# for all read size

# for reads > 2500 bp

Here are the two raw figures. All the reads:

Only reads >2500 bp:

Taxonomic composition

This section is divided into three distinct parts which relate to three different data input:

  • MinION long-reads
    • Samples: GT_1, GT_2, PC_1, PC_2, AE_1, AE_2
  • Short-read metagenomes
    • Samples: PB_2, TD
  • Short-read amplicon
    • Samples: TD

For each type of data, we have a different strategy to analysis their taxonomic composition. In brief, for the long-reads we recovered the 16S rRNA genes which we blasted against the Human Oral Microbiome Database (HOMD); for metagenomes, we followed anvi’o metagenomics workflow with the IDBA_UD assembler and used ribosomal protein with the Genome Taxonomy Database (GTDB) to compute taxonmic profiles; and for the 16S rRNA amplicon sequencing, we used Minimum Entropy Decomposition (MED) to generate oligotypes and the Silva database to assign taxonomy.

MinION long-reads

We can extract the 16S rRNA genes with the anvi’o command anvi-get-sequences-for-hmm-hits (not using the size-selection samples):

cd $WD

while read sample path; do
  if [ "$sample" == "sample" | "$sample" =~ "SS" ] || [[ "$sample" =~ "SS" ]]; then continue; fi;
    anvi-get-sequences-for-hmm-hits -c 04_CONTIGS/$sample-contigs.db \
                                    --hmm-source Ribosomal_RNAs \
                                    --gene-name Bacterial_16S_rRNA \
                                    -o 04_CONTIGS/$sample-16S_rRNA.fa
done < raw_reads.txt

We used the online HOMD blast tool to get taxonomic profile: We saved the top hit for each 16S rRNA sequence. Let’s download the table in a new directory 05_LR_TAXONOMY.

We need to create a table with the genus count per sample:

# remove empty lines with a single tab
for homd_out in `ls 05_LR_TAXONOMY/*HOMD*`; do
    sed '/^\t$/d' $homd_out > tmp
    mv tmp $homd_out

echo -e "sample\ttaxo\tcount" > 05_LR_TAXONOMY/genus-for-ggplot.txt
for homd_out in `ls 05_LR_TAXONOMY/*HOMD*txt`; do
  sample=`echo $homd_out | awk -F '-|/' '{print $2}'`
  for taxo in `cut -f5 $homd_out | sed 1d | cut -f1 -d ' ' | sort | uniq`; do
    count=`grep -c $taxo $homd_out`
    echo -e "$sample\t$taxo\t$count" >> 05_LR_TAXONOMY/genus-for-ggplot.txt

We will use this long-format table later to visualize taxonomic profile with ggplot2.

Short-read metagenomes

Let’s create a new directory dedicated to the metagenomics analsysis.

cd $WD

We will use anvi’o build in metagenomics workflow. Once again you can use the workflow command to genreate a default config file:

anvi-run-workflow -w metagenomics --get-default-config config.json

We will also need a samples.txt file with the name of the samples and the path to the read 1 and read 2 fastq files:

sample  r1  r2
PB_2  /path/to/PB_2-metagenome-R1.fastq  /path/to/PB_2-metagenome-R2.fastq
TD  /path/to/TD-metagenome-R1.fastq  /path/to/TD-metagenome-R2.fastq

Make sure to modify the config.json according to your setup (num of threads) and enable the IDBA_UD assembler. Here is a graph of that workflow:

Then we can use anvi-estimate-scg-taxonomy to get the taxonomic profile, using the most abundant ribosomal protein, here Ribosomal_S7. To do that, we need a metagenomes.txt file with the path to the contigs.db and profile.db:

name  contigs_db_path profile_db_path
PB_2  03_CONTIGS/PB_2-contigs.db	05_ANVIO_PROFILE/PB_2/PB_2/PROFILE.db

The command:

anvi-estimate-scg-taxonomy --compute-scg-coverages -M metagenomes.txt -O taxonomy

The output will be taxonomy-LONG-FORMAT.txt and it is ready to used in R with ggplot2.

Short-read amplicon

Once again, let’s create a new directory for the 16S rRNA analysis.

cd $WD
mkdir 07_SR_AMPLICON && cd 07_SR_AMPLICON

Quality filtering and merging

We will first use IlluminaUtils to remove low quality sequences, and merged the overlapping paired-end reads. To do that, we will need a first samples_qc.txt files with the name of the sample, path to read 1 and read 2.

sample  r1  r2
TD  /path/to/TD-amplicon-R1.fastq /path/to/TD-amplicon-R2.fastq

We can then run the quality filtering:

# genreate config file per sample
iu-gen-configs samples_qc.txt -o 01_QC

# run the quality filtering
iu-filter-quality-minoche 01_QC/TD.ini --ignore-deflines

For the paired-end merging, we need another files samples_merging.txt.

sample  r1  r2

Generate config files with the degenerate primer and barcode sequence:

iu-gen-configs samples_merging.txt \
               --r1-prefix ^TACGCCCAGCAGC[C,T]GCGGTAA. \
               --r2-prefix CCGTC[A,T]ATT[C,T].TTT[A,G]A.T \
               -o 02_MERGED

The actual command for the merging:

iu-merge-pairs 02_MERGED/TD.ini

Chimera detection and removal

To perform a chimera detection, we first need to dereplicate the reads, using vsearch:

vsearch --derep_fulllength 02_MERGED/TD_MERGED \
        --sizeout \
        --fasta_width 0 \
        --output 02_MERGED/TD_MERGED_DEREP \
        --threads 10

Then, still with vsearch, we can look for chimeric sequences and remove them:

vsearch --fasta_width 0 \
        --uchime_denovo 02_MERGED/TD_MERGED_DEREP \
        --nonchimeras 02_MERGED/TD_MERGED_DEREP_CHIMERA_FREE
        --threads 10

And prior to MED, we need to replicate the unique sequences:

vsearch --rereplicate 02_MERGED/TD_MERGED_DEREP_CHIMERA_FREE \
        --fasta_width 0 \
        --output 02_MERGED/TD_MERGED_CHIMERA_FREE \
        --threads 10

Minimum Entropy Decomposition

Now we have a set of merged and chimera free sequence and we can run MED:

# all sequences need to have the same length

# run MED
          -N 10 \
          -o 03_MED \

Taxonomy assignment

We used DADA2 in R and the Silva nr v132 database to assign taxonomy to the respresentative sequences from the MED analysis.

In R:



# import the nodes sequences
nodes <- readDNAStringSet("03_MED/NODE-REPRESENTATIVES.fasta")
nodes <-
nodes$name <- paste0("X", sapply(strsplit(rownames(nodes), "|", fixed = T), `[`, 1))

# import the count matrix
med_mat <- read.table("03_MED/MATRIX-COUNT.txt", header = T)

# assign the taxonomy with DADA2 and silva 132
# but first create the named fasta vector
med_tax <- assignTaxonomy(nodes$x,
                          multithread = 12,
                          minBoot = 80
rownames(med_tax) <- nodes[match(rownames(med_tax), nodes$x), "name"]

# replace NA by "Unclassified"
med_tax[] <- "Unclassified"

# Create the table for the stackedbar
med_mat_stack <- melt(med_mat)
# add the taxonomy
med_mat_stack$genus <- med_tax[match(med_mat_stack$variable, rownames(med_tax)), "Genus"]

# reshape the table
SR_16S <- med_mat_stack[, c(1, 4, 3)]
colnames(SR_16S) <- c("sample", "genus", "count")
SR_16S$group <- "Amplicon"
SR_16S <- group_by(SR_16S, sample, genus, group) %>% summarise(count = sum(count))
SR_16S <- SR_16S[, c(1,2,4,3)]

# export the final table
write.table(SR_16S, "SR_16S.txt", quote=F, sep="\t")

Combining all taxonomic profile into one figure

Now that we have taxonomic profiles for the three data type, we can create a stacked bar plot with all the samples.



#### LONG READS - 16S ---------------------------------------------------------
# import the data
LR_16S <- read.table("05_LR_TAXONOMY/genus-for-ggplot.txt",
                     header = T, stringsAsFactors = F)

# fix genus name
LR_16S[LR_16S == "Selenomonas_3"] <- "Selenomonas"
LR_16S[LR_16S == "Saccharibacteria"] <- "TM7x"
LR_16S[LR_16S == "Peptostreptococcaceae"] <- "Unclassified" # genus is unknown

# reformat
colnames(LR_16S) <- c("sample", "genus", "count")
LR_16S$group <- ifelse(grepl("oral_HMW_4", LR_16S$sample), "GT",
                       ifelse(grepl("oral_HMW_5", LR_16S$sample), "PC", "AE"))

#### Short-reads metagenome - Ribo protein ------------------------------------
# import the data
short_reads <- read.table("06_SR_METAGENOMICS/taxonomy-LONG-FORMAT.txt",
                          header = T, sep = "\t")

# reformat short_reads
SR_S7 <- short_reads[short_reads$taxonomic_level == "t_genus", ]
SR_S7 <- SR_S7[, 2:4]
colnames(SR_S7) <- c("sample", "genus", "count")
SR_S7$group <- "Metagenomes"
SR_S7$count <- as.numeric(SR_S7$count)

# 16S data - MED --------------------------------------------------------------
# import the data
SR_16S <- read.table("07_SR_AMPLICON/SR_16S.txt", header = T, sep = "\t")

#### A BIG FIGURE  ------------------------------------------------------------
# ... and in the darkness bind them
all_samples <- bind_rows(LR_16S, SR_S7, SR_16S)

# Make percentage per sample
all_samples <- group_by(all_samples, sample) %>% mutate(count = count / sum(count))

# Filter out < 1% and create a "rare" category
x <- 0.01
genus_rare <- group_by(all_samples[all_samples$count < x, ], sample, group) %>% summarise(count = sum(count))
genus_rare$genus <- "rare (<1%)"
all_samples <- all_samples[all_samples$count >= x, ]
all_samples <- bind_rows(all_samples, genus_rare)

# Simplify taxo name
all_samples$genus <- gsub("Unknown_genera", "Unclassified", all_samples$genus)
all_samples$genus <- gsub("Prevotella_6", "Prevotella", all_samples$genus)
all_samples$genus <- gsub("Prevotella_7", "Prevotella", all_samples$genus)
all_samples$genus <- gsub("F0040", "Unclassified", all_samples$genus)
all_samples$genus <- gsub("F0428", "Unclassified", all_samples$genus)

# order the taxonomy
all_samples$genus <- factor(all_samples$genus, levels = c(
  "Actinomyces", "Alloprevotella", "Anaeroglobus", "Atopobium",
  "Bacteroides", "Bulleidia", "Campylobacter", "Eremiobacter",
  "Fructilactobacillus", "Fusobacterium", "Granulicatella", "Haemophilus",
  "Kosakonia", "Lachnoanaerobaculum", "Lancefieldella", "Leptotrichia",
  "Megasphaera", "Neisseria", "Oribacterium", "Pauljensenia",
  "Porphyromonas", "Prevotella", "Rothia", "Selenomonas",
  "Solobacterium", "Stomatobaculum", "Streptococcus",
  "TM7x", "UBA2866", "Veillonella", "rare (<1%)", "Unclassified"))

colorlist <- data.frame(
  genus = c(
    "rare (<1%)",
  col = c(

# make sure the color list match the genus.
colorlist <- colorlist[colorlist$genus %in% unique(all_samples$genus), ]

# The figure
P <- function(df, tax_color, title = "") {
  p <- ggplot(df, aes(sample, count, fill = genus))
  p <- p + geom_bar(stat = "identity", position = "fill")
  p <- p + facet_grid(. ~ group, scales = "free_x", space = "free_x")
  p <- p + scale_fill_manual(values = as.vector(tax_color[[2]]), limits = as.vector(tax_color[[1]]))
  p <- p + theme(
    axis.ticks.x = element_blank(),
    strip.text.y = element_text(angle = 0, hjust = 0),
    panel.grid.minor = element_blank(),
    legend.position = "bottom",
    axis.text.x = element_text(angle = 90, hjust = 1))
  p <- p + ylab("Relative abundance")
  p <- p + xlab("Samples")
  p <- p + ggtitle(title)
  p <- p + scale_y_continuous(labels = percent)
P(all_samples, colorlist, "Taxonomic profiles")

Here is the raw figure, before a prettifying step in Inkscape:

Long-read assembly

In this part of the reproducible workflow, we are going to assemble the long-reads from GT_1, GT_2, PC_1, PC_2, AE_1 and AE_2. We will use the short-reads from PB_2 (because it all comes from the same pool of tongue scrapping) to polish the long-read contigs and anvi’o contigs workflow to summarize each assembly.

Among the few metagenomics assembler for long-reads, we chose to use Flye with the metagenomics option:

cd $WD

mdkir 08_LR_ASSEMBLY && cd 08_LR_ASSEMBLY

while read sample path; do
  if [ "$sample" == "sample" | "$sample" =~ "SS" ] || [[ "$sample" =~ "SS" ]]; then continue; fi;
  flye --nano-raw $path \
       --out-dir 08_LR_ASSEMBLY/$sample \
       --meta \
       --threads 16
done < raw_reads.txt

Then we will use Pilon to polish the contigs with short-reads. But Pilon is not a “one command line only”. We need to map the short reads to the contigs with minimap2, sort and index the bam file and then run Pilon. Let’l create a fasta_raw_assemblies.txt file with the name of samples, and path to the assemblies.

name  path
GT_1  $WD/08_LR_ASSEMBLY/GT_1/assembly.fasta
GT_2  $WD/08_LR_ASSEMBLY/GT_2/assembly.fasta
PC_1  $WD/08_LR_ASSEMBLY/PC_1/assembly.fasta
PC_2  $WD/08_LR_ASSEMBLY/PC_2/assembly.fasta
AE_1  $WD/08_LR_ASSEMBLY/AE_1/assembly.fasta
AE_2  $WD/08_LR_ASSEMBLY/AE_2/assembly.fasta

Now, let’s run Pilon!

while read name path
  if [ "$name" == "name" ]; then continue; fi
  minimap2 -t 6 \
           -ax map-ont $path \
           /path/to/PB_2-metagenome-R1.fastq \
           /path/to/PB_2-metagenome-R2.fastq \
           > 08_LR_ASSEMBLY/PILON/$name/$name.sam
done < fasta_raw_assemblies.txt

while read name path
  if [ "$name" == "name" ]; then continue; fi
  samtools sort 08_LR_ASSEMBLY/PILON/$name/$name.sam \
                -@ 6 \
                -o 08_LR_ASSEMBLY/PILON/$name/$name.bam
done < fasta_raw_assemblies.txt

while read name path
  if [ "$name" == "name" ]; then continue; fi
  samtools index 08_LR_ASSEMBLY/PILON/$name/$name.bam
done < fasta_raw_assemblies.txt

while read name path
  if [ "$name" == "name" ]; then continue; fi
  java -Xmx16G -jar /path/to/pilon-1.23-2/pilon-1.23.jar \
       --genome $path \
       --bam 08_LR_ASSEMBLY/PILON/$name/$name.bam \
       --outdir 08_LR_ASSEMBLY/PILON/$name \
       --output $name-pilon
done < fasta.txt

Once again we can create anvi’o contigs databases to summarize these assemblies. We can create an other file fasta_polished_assemblies.txt with the sample name and path to each assemblies:

name  path
GT_1_assembly  $WD/08_LR_ASSEMBLY/PILON/GT_1/GT_1.fasta
GT_2_assembly  $WD/08_LR_ASSEMBLY/PILON/GT_2/GT_2.fasta
PC_1_assembly  $WD/08_LR_ASSEMBLY/PILON/PC_1/PC_1.fasta
PC_2_assembly  $WD/08_LR_ASSEMBLY/PILON/PC_2/PC_2.fasta
AE_1_assembly  $WD/08_LR_ASSEMBLY/PILON/AE_1/AE_1.fasta
AE_2_assembly  $WD/08_LR_ASSEMBLY/PILON/AE_2/AE_2.fasta

You can copy the config.json used for the previous contigs workflow and update the name of the fasta.txt with fasta_polished_assemblies.txt. And run the workflow:

anvi-run-workflow -w contigs -c config.json

Finally, you can get the summary (number of contigs, total length, N50, number of genes, single-copy core genes, number of expected genomes) with anvi-display-contigs-stats:

anvi-display-contigs-stats -o 04_CONTIGS/contig_stats_assembly.txt 04_CONTIGS/*assembly*contigs.db